Election Insight: Macro-Strategy

Evaluating Biden's plan for America

David Joy | Vice President – Chief Market Strategist July 29, 2020

 

Former Vice President Joe Biden's presidential campaign has released several tax and spending proposals that together supply a rather detailed picture of the policy direction such an administration would take. This report provides a summary of those proposals and outlines some of their potential investment implications. It is important to keep in mind that even if the Biden campaign is successful in winning the White House, there is a significant difference between proposals and policy. How much any administration can accomplish is influenced quite heavily by the makeup of Congress, as well as circumstances in the economy and the country at-large.

SUMMARY

Taxes

The Biden campaign has proposed significant changes to the provisions of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA), including;

Business

  • The statutory corporate tax rate could rise to 28 percent from the current 21 percent. The TCJA had lowered the rate from 35 percent.
  • Institute a corporate alternative minimum tax of 15 percent.
  • Reduce the deduction to 25 percent on global intangible low tax income, effectively raising the tax rate to 21 percent from 10.5.
  • More broadly, institute various manufacturing tax credits, expand certain renewable energy tax credits, and eliminate fossil fuel subsidies.
  • End certain real estate tax loopholes and impose sanctions on tax havens and outsourcing. 

Individuals

  • Impose a payroll tax of 12.5 percent (Social Security) on incomes above $400K, half borne by the employer. This would result in the Social Security tax being imposed up to the current limit of $137.7K, followed by a gap up to $400k, and unlimited thereafter.
  • Reimpose the pre-TCJA top income tax bracket of 39.6 percent from the current 37 percent.
  • Tax dividends and capital gains at ordinary income tax rates for incomes above $1mm.

Spending

  • The Biden campaign has proposed a $2T first-term spending package designed to address environmental and climate concerns by enforcing and strengthening laws, targeting polluters, mitigating the impacts on the most vulnerable communities of color, and strengthening climate and healthcare infrastructure and preparedness, as well as, investing in the engines of sustainable job creation. Among its provisions are:
  • To invest in roads, bridges, railroads, light rail, airports, water, broadband, electric vehicles, wind, solar, batteries, economic electrification, 4mm building energy retrofits, hydrogen technology, nuclear technology, agriculture conservation and land management, clean brownfields, modernize schools, carbon capture, and secure sustainable U.S. supply chains.
  • Commit to a carbon-free electric grid by 2035, and a net-zero emission economy by 2050.
  • Free four-year public college tuition for families making less than $125K. Free community college and skills training as well as $70B investment in historically minority colleges.
  • $15 an hour federal minimum wage ($7.25 currently).
  • $400B Buy America procurement commitment.
  • $300B investment in new technology R&D.
  • 1.5mm sustainable, affordable housing units.
  • Enhance the ability of labor to organize.

The Biden campaign has also proposed a $775B program to bolster child and elderly care. Mr. Biden proposes universal pre-school for three-and four-year-old children, would end the waitlist for home and community services under Medicaid, and encourage in-home care alternatives. His plan provides a childcare tax credit of up to $8K for low-and middle-income families. The plan also proposes a pay increase for early childhood educators and elder caregivers, which could contribute to the creation of 3mm jobs. The plan would be paid for by taxing certain real estate transactions and enhanced tax compliance for those with incomes above $400K, including possibly ending like-kind exchanges.

Analysis

According to the Tax Foundation, the Biden tax plan would raise tax revenue by $3.8T over ten years using a conventional analysis methodology. Under a dynamic analysis methodology, which considers the impact of policy, the plan would raise $3.2T, with roughly half of the incremental tax revenue coming from each of the corporate and individual tax code changes. The Tax Foundation estimates the plan would lower GDP by 1.51 percent over the long-term and cost the economy 585K full-time equivalent jobs. According to the American Enterprise Institute, the tax plan would also raise $3.8T over ten years using conventional analysis, but $3.6T using a dynamic analysis. Mr. Biden's proposal is estimated to reduce GDP over the next ten years by 0.06 percent and by 0.2 percent over the long-term, and according to the analysis would have little significant impact on the budget deficit either in the short or long-term.

Both organization's analysis shows personal income taxes rising in all brackets, but only fractionally for those making less than $400K, and only due to the assumption that some of the increase in corporate taxes will be borne by employees in the form of lower wages. The AEI estimates that 72.2 percent of the first full-year tax increase on individuals will be borne almost exclusively by the top one percent of income earners, resulting in an average after-tax income decline for this group of 17.8 percent. Analysis by Ned Davis Research calculates that the rise in the statutory corporate rate could reduce S&P 500 earnings by 12.7 percent. However, the effective rate paid by corporations is typically lower than the statutory rate, most recently 17.7 percent in 2019. Since the effective rate fell by 6.6 percent following the TCJA, a fifty percent rollback of the reduction in the statutory rate would theoretically raise the effective rate to 21 percent. In that case, the decrease in S&P 500 earnings could fall by 4.2 percent.

Investment Implications

The climate and the environment are near the top of Mr. Biden's policy focus, so it stands to reason that alternative energy industries are likely to benefit from a Biden administration, including wind, solar, biofuels, electric vehicle, and battery manufacturers. Construction and engineering companies are also expected to benefit from his emphasis on infrastructure spending. To the extent that immigration policy might be quite different, industries that rely on immigrant labor across the skill spectrum may also benefit. Should trade policy be less focused on the use of tariffs, both importers and exporters may benefit. Certain healthcare providers may benefit as well, including hospitals and elder care providers. The potential industry losers in a Biden administration include fossil fuel companies, especially coal, defense-related industries, big technology as well as big banks (from a regulatory perspective), internal combustion vehicle manufacturers, luxury goods, union-heavy industries.

For a deeper dive into both the energy and healthcare sectors, please see the following Election Insight publications from the Investment Research Group;

"Energy Positioning into the Election," Will Foley, June 4, 2020, and "Healthcare Positioning into the Election," Dan Garofalo, May 13, 2020.

For a historical look at how broader stock averages have behaved in election years, please see our "Committee Perspectives: U.S. Election Guide." This publication examines past presidential election cycles, election uncertainty, and market volatility, and why the makeup of Congress matters, all in graphic form.

The content in this report is authored by American Enterprise Investment Services Inc. (“AEIS”) and distributed by Ameriprise Financial Services, LLC (“AFS”) to financial advisors and clients of AFS. AEIS and AFS are affiliates and subsidiaries of Ameriprise Financial, Inc. Both AEIS and AFS are member firms registered with FINRA and are subject to the objectivity safeguards and disclosure requirements relating to research analysts and the publication and distribution of research reports. The “Important Disclosures” below relate to the AEIS research analyst(s) that prepared this publication. The “Disclosures of Possible Conflicts of Interest” section, where applicable, relates to the conflicts of interest of each of AEIS and AFS, their affiliates and their research analysts, as applicable, with respect to the subject companies mentioned in the report.
Each of AEIS and AFS have implemented policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure that its employees involved in the preparation, content and distribution of research reports, including dually registered employees, do not influence the objectivity or timing of the publication of research report content. All research policies, coverage decisions, compensation, hiring and other personnel decisions with respect to research analysts are made by AEIS, which is operationally independent of AFS.
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES
As of June 30, 2020
The views expressed regarding the company(ies) and sector(s) featured in this publication reflect the personal views of the research analyst(s) authoring the publication. Further, no part of research analyst compensation is directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendations or views contained in this publication.
A part of a research analyst’s compensation may be based upon overall firm revenue and profitability, of which investment banking, sales and trading, and principal trading are components.
No part of a research analyst’s compensation is based on a specific investment banking transaction, nor is it based on sales, trading, or principal trading. A research analyst may have visited the material operations of one or more of the subject companies mentioned in this research report. No payment was received for the related travel costs.
Additional information and current research disclosures on individual companies mentioned in this research report are available on our website at ameriprise.com/legal/disclosures in the Additional Ameriprise research disclosures section, or through your Ameriprise financial advisor. You may also submit a written request to Ameriprise Financial, LLC, 1441 West Long Lake Road, Troy MI, 48098. Independent third party research on individual companies is available to clients at ameriprise.com/financial-news-research/. SEC filings may be viewed at sec.gov.
Tactical asset class recommendations mentioned in this report reflect The Ameriprise Global Asset Allocation Committee’s general view of the financial markets, as of the date of the report, based on then current conditions. Our tactical recommendations may differ materially from what is presented in a customized long-term financial plan or portfolio strategy. You should view our recommendations in conjunction with a broader long-term portfolio strategy. Not all products, services, or asset classes mentioned in this report may be available for sale at Ameriprise Financial Services, Inc. Please consult with your financial advisor.
Ameriprise Recommended List equities are equities that our analyst(s) believe offer attractive total return potential within their coverage universe based on current conditions. Your financial advisor can assist you with determining the risk profile of the Recommended List companies within the context of your overall investment portfolio. Additions and deletions are at the discretion of the analyst(s) covering the sector, with changes based upon such fundamental factors as valuation, competitive position, market conditions, etc. Furthermore, we have an internal sell discipline designed to potentially improve Recommended List performance and reduce risk. A Recommended List company that has generated returns in the bottom quartile of its respective S&P economic sector for three consecutive months will be flagged for review for possible removal from the Recommended List.
The Sector Recommended List is not designed to be a complete portfolio, but instead to assist in the selection of securities for the equity portion of a well-diversified portfolio. We believe it is important for investors to diversify their investments across asset classes, economic sectors and industries in order to help reduce risk. Please consult with your financial advisor to assist in creating a diversified portfolio that is consistent with your investment objectives.
Recommended List selections and securities markets in general could experience significant volatility due to several factors, including but not limited to: changes in global economic conditions, movements in interest & foreign exchange rates, fluctuations in commodity prices, geopolitical risks, changes in the regulatory & legislative environment (e.g. regulatory capital requirements, changes in tax rates, Medicare, etc.), catastrophes & natural disasters, labor issues, disruptions in the supply chain, merger integration issues, patent expiration, cybersecurity issues, litigation risks, headline risks, changes in distribution, and the loss of key personnel. For additional information please refer to third party research reports. You may experience a loss of principal by investing in equities.
Securities included on our Recommended Lists are selected from the universe of companies covered by AEIS. Approved third party research providers (e.g., CFRA powered by data from S&P Global, Morningstar, Reuters and Standard & Poor's) generally provide additional information on Recommended List companies. Recommended List selections reflect securities that our analysts believe represent good value based on current conditions. If a security is added to a Recommended List, we deem it to be appropriate for investment. If a security is removed from a Recommended List and you choose to hold the removed security in your investment portfolio, you should continue to review available third-party research sources in order to obtain an investment opinion, price target, and additional fundamental analysis. For ratings definition purposes, securities included on our Recommended Lists most closely correlate with an investment opinion of “Buy”; therefore, 100% of the securities on our Recommended Lists meet this definition. For purposes of constructing our Recommended List, a rating of “Buy” is defined as those securities that our research analysts believe represent good value based on current conditions. Additionally, we note that each of our respective approved third-party research providers utilizes its own unique rating system, which is disclosed and defined in its own research reports.
RISK FACTORS
Dividend and interest payments are not guaranteed. The amount of dividend payment, if any, can vary over time and issuers may reduce or eliminate dividends paid on securities in the event of a recession or adverse event affecting a specific industry or issuer. Should a company be unable to pay interest on a timely basis a default may occur and interruption or reduction of interest and principal occur.
Investments in a narrowly focused sector may exhibit higher volatility than investments with broader objectives and is subject to market risk and economic risk.
INDEX DEFINITIONS
An index is a statistical composite that is not managed. It is not possible to invest directly in an index.
Definitions of individual indices mentioned in this report are available on our website at ameriprise.com/legal/disclosures/ in the Additional Ameriprise research disclosures section, or through your Ameriprise financial advisor.
DISCLAIMER SECTION
Except for the historical information contained herein, certain matters in this report are forward-looking statements or projections that are dependent upon certain risks and uncertainties, including but not limited to, such factors and considerations as general market volatility, global economic and geopolitical impacts, fiscal and monetary policy, liquidity, the level of interest rates, historical sector performance relationships as they relate to the business and economic cycle, consumer preferences, foreign currency exchange rates, litigation risk, competitive positioning, the ability to successfully integrate acquisitions, the ability to develop and commercialize new products and services, legislative risks, the pricing environment for products and services, and compliance with various local, state, and federal health care laws. See latest third-party research reports and updates for risks pertaining to a particular security.
This summary is based upon financial information and statistical data obtained from sources deemed reliable, but in no way is warranted by Ameriprise Financial, Inc. as to accuracy or completeness. This is not a solicitation by Ameriprise Financial Services, LLC of any order to buy or sell securities. This summary is based exclusively on an analysis of general current market conditions, rather than the appropriateness of a specific proposed securities transaction. We will not advise you as to any change in figures or our views.
Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
AFS and its affiliates do not offer tax or legal advice. Consumers should consult with their tax advisor or attorney regarding their specific situation.
Investment products are not federally or FDIC-insured, are not deposits or obligations of, or guaranteed by any financial institution, and involve investment risks including possible loss of principal and fluctuation in value.
Third party companies mentioned are not affiliated with Ameriprise Financial, Inc.
Ameriprise Financial Services, LLC. Member FINRA and SIPC.